Renting vs. Buying in Dayton is becoming one of the most important financial decisions facing local families in 2025. With rising rents, recent tax law changes, and a growing range of programs that help renters become homeowners, it has never been more important to understand the true cost difference between renting and buying in Dayton.
For many years, renting felt simpler. But today, long-term renters in Dayton are facing a combination of rising housing costs, higher tax burdens passed down from landlords, and insurance increases—all while homeownership remains relatively affordable compared to most major cities.
This guide breaks down the real numbers, the new tax incentives, and the long-term advantages of homeownership in Dayton. By the end, you’ll have a clear, honest picture of whether renting or buying makes more financial sense in 2025.
The State of Renting in Dayton in 2025
Renting has been common in Dayton because monthly payments feel predictable. But in reality, renting has become more expensive year after year. Across much of the city—especially in West Dayton, Northwest Dayton, and Twin Towers—rent for a single-family home now ranges between $850 and $1,300 per month.
Even if your rent starts at $1,000 a month, natural rent inflation quickly adds up:
- Year 1: $1,000
- Year 2: $1,030
- Year 3: $1,061
- Year 4: $1,093
- Year 5: $1,125
Over five years, a renter will spend roughly $60,000, with nothing to show for it in terms of equity or long-term financial stability.
Renters also face other risks:
- The landlord sells the property
- Market rents increase faster than income
- Insurance and property tax hikes get passed into rent
- Zero control over stability or improvements
In Dayton’s current market, renting exposes families to increasing uncertainty—while the cost to buy remains comparatively stable and often cheaper.
How New Tax Changes Make Renting More Expensive and Homeownership More Affordable
Two major tax changes taking effect between 2024–2025 have dramatically shifted the financial landscape for Dayton renters.
1. Dayton voted in a citywide property tax increase
This means landlords will face higher operating costs—costs they must pass to renters to stay financially stable. The result: renters in Dayton should expect higher rents over the next 1–2 years.
2. Ohio eliminated the 10% non-business tax credit for landlords
For decades, landlords in Ohio received a 10% tax reduction on investment properties. That discount is now gone. Rental properties now cost 10% more in taxes to own than they did previously.
Again, renters pay this difference through higher rent.
3. Ohio introduced a new 15% property tax credit for homeowners
This is the most important shift of all. Homeowners now receive a 15% direct tax credit on their property taxes for owner-occupied homes.
The result is a 25%–35% swing in tax treatment.
- Renters indirectly pay higher taxes through increased rent.
- Homeowners directly pay less in taxes through a 15% credit.
In real numbers, this can mean saving hundreds—or even thousands—of dollars in property taxes annually simply by choosing to own the home rather than rent it.
The Real Cost of Buying a Home in Dayton
Despite rising rents, Dayton remains one of the most affordable homeownership markets in the Midwest. In 2025, many homes fall within the following ranges:
- Home prices: $85,000–$140,000
- Mortgage payments: $650–$1,050 per month
- Taxes + insurance: $150–$250 per month
In neighborhoods like Westwood, Hillcrest, Wesleyan Hill, Residence Park, and parts of Wright-Dunbar, buying a home is often the same price—or cheaper—than renting.
Renting vs. Buying in Dayton: A Real-Life Example
Example home:
3-bedroom home in Northwest Dayton
Purchase Price: $105,000
If you rent this home:
- Monthly rent: $1,000
- Annual cost: $12,000
- Five-year total: $60,000
- Equity: $0
If you buy this home:
- Principal + Interest @ 6.25%: ~$650
- Taxes + Insurance: ~$200
- Total monthly: ~$850
- Five-year total: ~$51,000
- Equity after five years: $9,000–$22,000+
You save roughly $9,000 over five years and gain tens of thousands in equity.
How Renters Pay More for Insurance Than Homeowners in Dayton
Most renters don’t realize they’re paying for two insurance policies every month:
- Their own renters insurance ($18–$28/month)
- The landlord’s dwelling fire policy (included in rent)
Meanwhile, homeowners insurance—far more comprehensive—typically costs only $75–$120 per month in Dayton.
Renters pay more for less coverage.
When you own your home:
- You stop paying the landlord’s insurance indirectly
- You qualify for better coverage
- You benefit from Ohio’s new 15% property tax credit
- Your money protects your equity instead of your landlord’s
Want to see what homeowners insurance would cost for the type of home you want to buy?
Get a Homeowners Insurance Quote
Why Traditional Rent-to-Own Models Don’t Work
Rent-to-own schemes and land contracts have harmed Dayton families for decades. They often involve:
- Inflated rents
- Hidden fees
- Non-refundable “option” payments
- Unfair forfeiture clauses
Your program is fundamentally different—and far more transparent.
Our Approach: Rent Today, Buy When You’re Ready
✔ Standard rental agreement
No premium rent, no hidden fees, and no misleading promises.
✔ Buy the home at any time you’re ready
If you love the home you’re renting and want to own it, we help you transition smoothly.
✔ Down payment assistance built into the purchase
Because we own the home, we can include part (or all) of your down payment into the sale—making ownership accessible even if you don’t have savings.
✔ Transparent, ethical, and affordable
No rent credits, no land contract tricks—just a real path to owning a home.
Why Buying Is Now Cheaper Than Renting in Dayton
When you combine:
- Rising rents from tax increases
- Lower monthly mortgage payments
- Homeowner tax credits
- Lower insurance costs
- Down payment help
- The ability to buy your current rental home
Owning becomes cheaper within 12–24 months for most Dayton families.
The Biggest Concerns Dayton Renters Have About Buying a Home (and Our Full, Honest Answers)
Every week, we hear the same questions from renters across West Dayton, Northwest Dayton, Twin Towers, and Old North Dayton. Most renters want to become homeowners—but they’ve been discouraged, misled, or simply don’t know where to begin. Below we break down the three most common concerns we hear and exactly how we address each one in a transparent, step-by-step way.
1. “I don’t know where to start.”
Most renters have never been taught how the home-buying process works. Schools don’t cover it. Landlords don’t explain it. And many online resources are full of jargon that only makes the process feel more intimidating.
We begin by giving you a tailored to your situation. Once you complete the soft credit check with our lending partner, we walk you through:
- Where you stand today in terms of credit, income, and purchasing power
- How much home you can realistically afford in Dayton’s current market
- Which neighborhoods fit your budget and long-term goals
- Which down payment programs you qualify for (including our built-in assistance)
- What paperwork you’ll need and how to get it
- Your timeline to becoming a homeowner—this could be 30 days or 18 months
Many renters feel overwhelmed because they’re trying to navigate the entire process alone. We remove that burden by acting as a guide from the moment you express interest until the day you’re holding your keys. You do not need to figure this out by yourself.
2. “My credit isn’t perfect.”
This is the most common concern—and the most misunderstood. Many Dayton renters assume they need excellent credit to buy a home. That simply isn’t true. In fact, most first-time homebuyers in Dayton have imperfect credit, medical collections, late payments, or old debts. You are not alone.
Our lending partner, Lance Tearnan of Texana Bank, starts with a soft credit check that does not show up on your credit report and does not impact your score. This gives us a clean snapshot of:
- Your credit strengths
- Your credit challenges
- What needs to be worked on
- What loan programs you may qualify for today
Based on that, we build a personalized improvement plan. This might include small, manageable steps like paying down a specific balance, adding one low-limit credit card, resolving an old utility bill, or correcting inaccurate items on your report.
The key is this: You don’t need perfect credit—just a path forward. Most Dayton renters are much closer to qualifying for a mortgage than they realize. The hardest part is making the first move.
If you are renting or will rent from Proper Management today, you are already building positive momentum toward homeownership.
Our Resident Benefits Package includes positive-only credit reporting. This means that every month you pay your rent on time, a positive payment is reported to the credit bureaus—helping strengthen your credit profile over time.
This is important because most renters never receive credit for their largest monthly payment. But under our program, you do. On-time rent payments can help:
- Increase your credit score over time
- Strengthen your mortgage readiness
- Offset older negative items on your report
- Show lenders a pattern of responsible payment behavior
Even if your credit isn’t perfect today, these consistent positive rent payments are already laying the foundation for your future mortgage approval. It means you may be closer than you think—and the soft credit check simply gives us a clear starting point.
3. “I can’t afford a down payment.”
Saving $5,000–$10,000 for a down payment can feel impossible, especially when rents increase yearly. We understand that. That’s why our approach is designed to remove the biggest financial barrier between renters and homeownership.
Because we are the property owner, we can structure the sale in a way that includes down payment assistance directly within the purchase. This is not a loan you must repay. This is not a rent-credit scheme. This is not a land contract or lease-option trick. This is a genuine, transparent way to help you buy a home without needing to save large sums upfront.
Our goal is to help renters build stability—not to trap them in another cycle of unreachable requirements. With our model, you can:
- Rent the home you’re already living in
- Build a plan with your lender based on your actual credit
- Start preparing financially at your own pace
- Buy the home when you’re ready—with assistance to make it possible
For many Dayton renters, the combination of down payment assistance, affordable home prices, and the new 15% Ohio homeowner tax credit creates an opportunity that simply didn’t exist a few years ago. The biggest barrier isn’t money—it’s clarity. And that’s what we help you gain.
See Where You Stand (Soft Credit Check, No Impact)
Knowing your buying power is free, simple, and risk-free.
Start Your Free Pre-Approval Check
Explore Homes Available in Dayton Proper
See homes available to buy today—or rent with the option to buy when you’re ready.